Substackers Against Nazis

A collective letter to Substack leadership

Hi all, it looks like Substack has a Nazi bar problem. Some 220 of us (and counting) object to this. As you know I’ve made efforts in the past to raise the issue of the platforming and promotion of hate on Substack. The issue has been raised again, following a recent article by Jonathan M. Katz in The Atlantic. Below is a letter to the Substack founders drafted by a group of publishers seeking answers to questions about the platforming and monetizing of Nazis. We are all publishing the letter on our own individual Substacks for visibility, and to make our readers aware of our asks and concerns.

I originally posted this on my other publication, but I thought I’d “make assurance double sure” and post it here too. And yes, I’ve already had verbal abuse because of it, and am considering my future presence here.

Sharon


Dear Chris, Hamish & Jairaj:

We’re asking a very simple question that has somehow been made complicated: Why are you platforming and monetizing Nazis? 

According to a piece written by Substack publisher Jonathan M. Katz and published by The Atlantic on November 28, this platform has a Nazi problem: 

“Some Substack newsletters by Nazis and white nationalists have thousands or tens of thousands of subscribers, making the platform a new and valuable tool for creating mailing lists for the far right. And many accept paid subscriptions through Substack, seemingly flouting terms of service that ban attempts to ‘publish content or fund initiatives that incite violence based on protected classes’…Substack, which takes a 10 percent cut of subscription revenue, makes money when readers pay for Nazi newsletters.”

As Patrick Casey, a leader of a now-defunct neo-Nazi group who is banned on nearly every other social platform except Substack, wrote on here in 2021: “I’m able to live comfortably doing something I find enjoyable and fulfilling. The cause isn’t going anywhere.” Several Nazis and white supremacists including Richard Spencer not only have paid subscriptions turned on but have received Substack “Bestseller” badges, indicating that they are making at a minimum thousands of dollars a year.

From our perspective as Substack publishers, it is unfathomable that someone with a swastika avatar, who writes about “The Jewish question,” or who promotes Great Replacement Theory, could be given the tools to succeed on your platform. And yet you’ve been unable to adequately explain your position. 

In the past you have defended your decision to platform bigotry by saying you “make decisions based on principles not PR” and “will stick to our hands-off approach to content moderation.” But there’s a difference between a hands-off approach and putting your thumb on the scale. We know you moderate some content, including spam sites and newsletters written by sex workers. Why do you choose to promote and allow the monetization of sites that traffic in white nationalism? 

Your unwillingness to play by your own rules on this issue has already led to the announced departures of several prominent Substackers, including Rusty Foster and Helena Fitzgerald. They follow previous exoduses of writers, including Substack Pro recipient Grace Lavery and Jude Ellison S. Doyle, who left with similar concerns. 

As journalist Casey Newton told his more than 166,000 Substack subscribers after Katz’s piece came out: “The correct number of newsletters using Nazi symbols that you host and profit from on your platform is zero.” 

We, your publishers, want to hear from you on the official Substack newsletter. Is platforming Nazis part of your vision of success? Let us know—from there we can each decide if this is still where we want to be.

Signed, 

Substackers Against Nazis

Substackers against Nazis

Thanks for reading. If this letter resonates, please share this post with others. If you’re a publisher who would like to join this collective effort, we encourage you to repost the letter on your own Substack.

Sharon

LinkedIn Update 19 October 2023

Hi everyone,

I haven’t yet settled on a cadence for these updates, but given that there’s been a lot happening, I thought it was time for another one.

  • I had some epiphanies about this newsletter, including the fact that if everyone who follows me on LinkedIn subscribed here, there would be enough momentum so I could publish mostly here and only occasionally there – and reach ALL the people who are interested in my work and my content, not just those that LinkedIn deigns to let past their gatekeeping algorithm.

  • I celebrated publishing 400 posts on SARN, where the most popular recent post was this open letter to a friend who’d offered support after a racist incident.

  • There was a post on why the Barbados launch of my book will be super simple.

And then there was this, about Palestine and Israel:

I’ve been trying to gather my words for days but they remain stubbornly ungathered. So here’s where I am:

I’ve felt ill-informed and have been trying to fill my knowledge gaps without resorting to biased media outlets.

So I’ve been listening to and learning from my Muslim and Jewish friends, and will continue to do so.

Here are the things I know and hold to:

There is no excuse for genocide.
There is no excuse for killing innocent civilians.
There is no excuse for apartheid.
Oppression is wrong.
Occupation is wrong.
And nothing good ever came from colonialism or imperialism.

As a Black woman, watching people spew vitriol on other Global Majority people awakens all kinds of trauma, both generational and from my own experience. The inhumanity of killing innocents is also traumatic.

I will not celebrate anyone’s death. And I will not countenance Islamophobia or antisemitism. (Immediate block and report if anyone does that on my post.)

That is all for now.

P.S. I’ve been following Rahimeh Ramezany 🧕🏻 and Emily O. Weltman, M. Ed. (among many others) as part of questioning all the things and getting better informed.

Their posts have a wealth of information, so they’re a good place to start if you’ve been in a similar space.

We also posted a statement on Mission Equality’s social media, which has just gone out in our newsletter.

The Path To Equality
Both/And: Moving Beyond The Binary
At Mission Equality, we see and acknowledge binary thinking as an often harmful and divisive approach, used by design to uphold the status quo… It’s not either or, it’s both and. People keep trying to insist that if you support one thing, you’re against the other…
Read more

This post from Abi Adamson is also worth reading.

What with everything, it’s been a heavy few weeks, and that doesn’t look like changing any time soon. Hope you are all finding moments of peace and rest where you can.

Thanks for being here,

Sharon

LinkedIn Update 28 September 2023

Hi all,

I sometimes wonder why I even bother posting on LinkedIn – though it’s where most people find me, visibility is way, way down – dropping by 60% in the past week. It’s why I’ve decided to do an occasional roundup of the stuff I’d really like you to see that I’ve posted on LinkedIn, so you can check it out if you want.

  • I’ve been posting more on our Mission Equality page as part of getting the word out about what we’re doing. This gallery talks about our Black Paper.

  • I shared a post on the #OneDaysPay initiative from Erin Corine Johnson, and made a surprise guest appearance on her live. Catch the replay.

  • I shared Lea’s post on our recent trip to Milwaukee. More to come from both of us on that.

I also pointed people to this post on my anti-racism newsletter – how many fingers would you hold up?

Sharon’s Anti-Racism Newsletter
“Never Have I Ever” – Anti-Racism Edition
Hello friends, The other day I was thinking about some of the experiences I’ve had living in or visiting white dominated countries. I started writing them down, then divided them into categories, and it struck me that these might make a good conversation game, along the lines of “never have I ever”, but without the need for excessive or any alcohol consumption…
Read more

One of the best things I read this week was this post from Emily O. Weltman – it probably deserves a feature in the anti-racism newsletter, but I’m including it here for now.

I’m keeping this short and sweet, so that’s it for now. This newsletter is free to read so feel free to share it with anyone who might be interested.

Until next time,

Sharon

Looking for SARN interviewees

I’m republishing some of my social media content – a version of this was posted on LinkedIn earlier this year.

One of the aims of my newsletter is to amplify Black writers, activists, and founders via my interview series. I’d love to publish at least 10 more interviews in 2023.

Overall subscriber numbers are just over the 5500 mark (just over 300 paid – thank you!), plus I share the interviews on LinkedIn to however many of my 19k followers manage to see the posts. The anecdotal evidence so far is that people who read the interviews spend time checking out the people featured, which may result in support for their ventures or additional publicity.

Until now, I’ve approached most interviewees myself, with a few recommendations here and there from trusted colleagues. However, as my commitments have grown, that seems inefficient, so I’m opening it up for people doing great things to let me know. (No shoddy marketing pitches, please!)

Here are my criteria:

  • Black women are at the head of the line for a spot (my way of redressing a common imbalance). However, I have also featured Black men and a couple of people of the Global Majority.

  • Whether you’re a Black founder, activist, or writer, you’re filling a gap or redressing an inequity, especially for your local or national Black community or the Black diaspora.

  • You are happy to do a written interview via a Google Form.

If you meet these criteria, DM me on LinkedIn or reply to this email and let me know whether you prefer to be in the Black founder series, Building Our Own Table, or the writer and activist interview series, and what inequity you’re countering. I’ll take a look at your LinkedIn profile and if it looks like a good fit, I’ll send you a link to the form. (No, I won’t post the links publicly, because trolls.)

Once you send in your interview, I’ll review your submission (it’s likely to be lightly edited for length, as I aim for 800-1000 words in all) and will let you know if I am able to publish it and when that’s likely to be. Publication will be on a first come, first served basis. Once I hit my target, I’ll close submissions till I have published most of the interviews received. But if you have something REALLY good and timely to share, message me and we’ll see what can happen.

If you want to know what your interviews will look like, I’ve dropped some examples below.

A great Building Our Own Table interview with Janelle Benjamin

Sharon’s Anti-Racism Newsletter
Building Our Own Table: Janelle Benjamin
Hello friends, in the last 18 months, I’ve heard many people say “we Black people don’t want a seat at the table, we want our OWN table”. And I’ve seen lots of Black people set up ventures to do things their way, and to redress historic and systemic inequities. This new interview series, “Building Our Own Table”, will feature some of them…
Read more

A great activist interview with Ashani Mfuko

Sharon’s Anti-Racism Newsletter
Meet Anti-Racism Activist Ashani Mfuko
Hello friends, Ashani Mfuko first came to my attention because she was posting dance videos on LinkedIn. These weren’t any ordinary dance videos, though. They were videos highlighting serious messages about racism and anti-racism. I’ve always thought it was a super-smart way to make people stop and look, and then to deliver the truths they needed to hear…
Read more

All interviews

Thanks, and I look forward to featuring some of you in my newsletter.

Please feel free to share this post with anyone you think is doing great work and should be featured.

I nearly missed SARN's third anniversary

I nearly missed it – it’s the third anniversary of the launch of SARN! In that time I’ve published 385 posts and 30 podcast episodes – many more to come!

In recognition of this milestone, I’m offering a flash discount – for the next three days, you can pick up an annual subscription at the 2020 rate via this link. Offer ends August 28th.


Check out the about page to see what you get and how existing supporters feel about SARN. And read some of the comments on this LinkedIn post.

Finally, here are some of the posts that people have loved recently.

Sharon’s Anti-Racism Newsletter
Black Spaces Matter
Hello friends, I’ve been thinking a lot recently of the importance of me, as a Black woman, having spaces where I can let my shoulders drop. In many cases, that means having spaces where all the members or participants are Black. Before I dive into why it matters, let me make a couple of things clear…
Read more
Sharon’s Anti-Racism Newsletter
Racism Stories: Microaggressions at Work
Hello friends, Kara Smith is one of my sister-friends from the FLOWLab – and a constant fount of wisdom. So when she said she had a story to share about an experience of microaggressions at work, I immediately knew I wanted to feature it in the “Racism Stories” section. Please read on to hear what happened to Kara, and how she recommends folx deal with …
Read more
Sharon’s Anti-Racism Newsletter
You Can’t Win With Some People
Hello friends, In thinking about my recent Substack Notes experience, one thing has become clear. Black folx and Black women in particular can’t really “win” when it comes to talking about racism. Not that there are truly any winners here. When I look back over my choices at the time, they were limited. I could have said nothing, and let people go on spe…
Read more

Thanks for reading

Sharon

Personal Reflections on Equal Futures

Hey folx, I’m finally gathering my thoughts after Mission Equality CIC ‘s recent Equal Futures event. (As an introvert, I needed some recovery time after a full day of being on, plus 5 subsequent days of family and friend activities, lol.)

Before I get to the event itself, a few words about Lea Jovy-Ford 🏳️‍🌈 who created both the concept (getting as many people as possible committed to equality in one room) and delivery method (themed conversation tables, discussion prompts, action plan guides and more) for Equal Futures.

I’ve known Lea for about 15 years. She’s a truly innovative thinker AND has the implementation know-how to make her ideas reality. I’ve seen her do it with several businesses. We talk regularly – almost daily – and conversations with her make my brain light up in the best way.

Lea doesn’t tend to shout about it, but the vast majority of the magical inspiration that characterises our company starts with her. Equal Futures was no exception, and I think she deserves her flowers, don’t you?

The proof of the pudding, so to speak, was in the experience attendees had. Summarising the comments we’ve had so far, Equal Futures offered a safe space for all, a majority Global Majority discussion space, a chance to forge and solidify connections with others of like mind, and an impetus for action.

One solid plan for improving Black women’s access to finance came out of the event, and the seeds of many more were planted.

Big, big thanks to everyone who came and participated. It was a joy to meet IRL so many people I’ve chatted to online, and the energy in the room was electric.

We are determined to create space to keep the momentum going, so Mission Equality has created a group for attendees where the connections and ideas made at Equal Futures can be strengthened, and where we can take action on a future that works better for all of us.

I’m excited to see what comes next as the conversations continue!

London, Here I Come!

Well, that should actually be “England, here I come” as I’m travelling to Manchester for my daughter’s graduation, to Nottingham to catch up with friends and family, and to London for a Mission Equality event. There’ll be a lot going on, and I plan to enjoy all of it.

In terms of the event, I’m looking forward to the rarity of being in the same room as two of my colleagues – Lea and AJ – for a couple of days. And I’m looking forward to our “DEI with a difference” event, where attendees will get access to our next Black Paper and we’ll be working on taking action on the path to equality.

The event is called “Equal Futures”, and we describe it as “The most progressive ‘DEI’ event you’ve ever been to…so progressive, it’s not really even a DEI event…”. That’s a big claim, I know, but if you’ve read our first Black Paper, you’ll know how differently we think about everything.

We’re determined that this won’t just be another talking shop. While it will facilitate conversations among practitioners focussed on equity and equality and our advocates, the intention is to plan how we can take action to create an equal future for all of us.

If you’re likely to be in or near London on July 14th, we hope you’ll join us.

The Stats Behind My Anti-Racism Newsletter

Substack launched a new dashboard recently. (I’m still there for now, though I think I’ve found my new platform – there are a couple of features on the roadmap that still need to be rolled out before I can make a seamless transition.)

But anyway, the new dashboard allowed me to discover some stats:

  • 365 pieces published, including:

  • 211 articles

  • 63 interviews

  • 33 reading lists (which equals nearly 400 articles by other writers shared in the last 2.5 years)

  • 28 behind the scenes letters

  • 30 podcast episodes

That’s a lot!

Right now I have 5200+ subscribers and 320+ supporters. My initial goal is to increase the number of supporters to 500 (which, frankly, will help cover my bills). If you want to become one of them, the linky goodness is below.

Remembering George Floyd – and Writing About Racism

My first article about racism happened four years before George Floyd was murdered. But his death was the catalyst for my decision to focus on promoting equality and fighting racism as my purpose. #

Today, I’m reissuing the poem I wrote on the one-year anniversary of his death and wondering where all that black square energy went in supposed allies?

Sharon’s Anti-Racism Newsletter
Remembering George Floyd
Hello friends, I have no wise words today. It’s all been said. All I can offer is an updated version of the poem I wrote on the one year anniversary. IT’S BEEN THREE YEARS It’s been three years Since George Floyd’s murder shook the world Nine minutes and 29 seconds of videoed trauma…
Read more

For those who are wondering, here’s that first piece.

Thanks for reading,

Sharon

You can't erase anti-racism from DEI

I’m republishing some of my social media content – this was posted on LinkedIn earlier this year.

When something happens, my natural inclination in many cases is to reach out and try to bridge gaps in understanding. Not everyone responds – that’s their call. And sometimes I wonder if I should have done it at all. I’m still wondering about the most recent example…

I reached out over the recent “DEI is not just about race” debacle for two reasons:

1. That statement seemed out of step with what I knew of the person who said it. (Others have had VERY different experiences, I’ve since learned.)

2. I hoped to help her see what she was clearly missing about the post and her subsequent comments.

While DEI looks after all the isms, the way that post was phrased felt like a weapon that attempted to exclude the necessary foundation of anti-racism from DEI. (Yes, necessary. Yes, foundation.) We all know when you address racism and anti-Blackness with policies and actions, ALL other groups who face isms benefit. That is a fact. DEI wouldn’t even be a thing without attempts to deal with racism in the Civil Rights Movement.

As I pointed out, whatever the original intention of her post, the impact was harm, compounded by insulting the Black women who took a different view. More harm, in other words. That was not ok.

By the end of our discussion, the harmful impact had been acknowledged, at least to me. My final message suggested that a public apology was in order, though whether it would be enough at this point was doubtful.

Sadly, somewhere in there, the post was deleted and the account was deactivated. That’s disappointing, but also familiar.

We all mess up. When we do we must hold our hands up, apologise and attempt repair. If we choose not to, then that says something too.

P.S. After I drafted this, someone else came with the same BS (no, I’m not linking to it). This in a few days where:

– Queen Angela Bassett was ignored, then slated for not fixing her face for the white gaze

– Posts celebrating Ms Bassett’s body of work were attacked by people spouting racism and misogynoir (see Lisa Hurley’s recent post on this)

– A major leadership organisation failed to make it right with the Black and Global Majority members it’s been failing

– A WSJ journalist tried to blame the SVB banking debacle on diversity

– It’s white women’s Equal Pay Day (Black, Indigenous and Latine women will be waiting till MUCH later in the year)

Please make it stop. We are TIRED!

And you can’t erase dealing with racism and anti-Blackness from DEI.